← ThenPath Weekly

Weekly - 10/13/2026

Defensives beat tech by 6.4 points. Is that bearish?

In 22 past near-high defensive turns, SPY’s median next month was +1.4%. The all-day baseline was also +1.4%.

Defensives = equal-weight Utilities and Consumer Staples, versus Technology.

Next-month SPY returns: medians and middle 50% NEXT-MONTH SPY RETURN Defensive turnsn = 22+1.4%All eligible daysn = 6,616+1.4%Near-high daysn = 3,562+1.2% -4%-2%0%+2%+4%+6% Bars = middle 50% · dots = medians · not the full range
Next-month SPY returns: medians and middle 50% NEXT-MONTH SPY RETURN Defensive turnsn = 22+1.4%All eligible daysn = 6,616+1.4%Near-high daysn = 3,562+1.2% -4%-2%0%+2%+4%+6% Bars = middle 50% · dots = medians
Middle 50%, not full ranges or confidence intervals. Daily baseline windows overlap.

Typical month resembled the baseline. That alone gives little support for a bearish reading.

17/22 positive monthsWorst month -5.8%Small, descriptive sample
Explore the 22 cases, including the losses ↓

Download the social graphic

The losses and alternative definitionsEach dot is one completed historical eventALL 22 EVENT MONTHS2000-01-07: -1.0% next-month SPY2000-09-06: -3.4% next-month SPY2003-07-22: +1.3% next-month SPY2004-02-02: +1.5% next-month SPY2005-12-14: +0.9% next-month SPY2007-01-22: +2.5% next-month SPY2011-03-11: +1.7% next-month SPY2012-04-19: -5.8% next-month SPY2013-04-17: +6.6% next-month SPY2014-03-14: -0.5% next-month SPY2015-07-07: +1.0% next-month SPY2016-04-28: +1.3% next-month SPY2017-06-15: +1.2% next-month SPY2018-07-30: +3.6% next-month SPY2019-09-24: +1.4% next-month SPY2020-11-12: +3.2% next-month SPY2021-12-06: +2.4% next-month SPY2023-07-24: -3.5% next-month SPY2024-01-31: +6.2% next-month SPY2024-08-26: +2.0% next-month SPY2025-05-20: +0.5% next-month SPY2025-12-15: +2.0% next-month SPY-6%-3%0%+3%+6%

17 positive months, 5 losing months. The worst next month was -5.8%; the worst six-month result was -15.7%. Individual outcomes are observations, not probabilities for today.

Defensive leadEventsMedian 1M
2pp near highs34+0.5%
4pp near highs14+1.3%
3pp at any level43+1.2%

At the prespecified 2pp near-high threshold, the median next month was +0.5%. The result depends on the definition.

Explore 22 completed cases and 1 pending
Event1M3M6M
2000-01-07-1.0%+4.2%+1.9%
2000-09-06-3.4%-7.7%-14.5%
2003-07-22+1.3%+6.3%+17.1%
2004-02-02+1.5%-1.3%-2.6%
2005-12-14+0.9%+3.1%-1.1%
2007-01-22+2.5%+4.4%+9.0%
2011-03-11+1.7%-2.1%-10.6%
2012-04-19-5.8%+0.5%+7.3%
2013-04-17+6.6%+8.9%+10.5%
2014-03-14-0.5%+5.6%+8.8%
2015-07-07+1.0%-4.1%-2.1%
2016-04-28+1.3%+5.0%+4.1%
2017-06-15+1.2%+3.1%+10.5%
2018-07-30+3.6%-4.8%-3.4%
2019-09-24+1.4%+9.1%-15.7%
2020-11-12+3.2%+11.5%+18.5%
2021-12-06+2.4%-9.0%-8.8%
2023-07-24-3.5%-6.9%+7.6%
2024-01-31+6.2%+3.9%+13.2%
2024-08-26+2.0%+6.5%+5.0%
2025-05-20+0.5%+8.0%+12.0%
2025-12-15+2.0%-2.5%+9.5%
2026-06-29-1.6%+3.6%Pending

01 / MACRO RHYME

Closest Macro Rhyme:
May 2006

Similar inflation, lower unemployment today.

CPI inflation · now / then3.4% ≈ 3.4%
Unemployment · now / then4.1% < 4.7%

Closest does not mean reliable. Removing one indicator changes the historical period.

What matches, and what differs

Inflation is 3.35% versus 3.42%. Unemployment is 4.1% versus 4.7%; the policy rate is 3.63% versus 4.59%; the 10Y–2Y curve is 0.44 versus 0.20 percentage points.

Without the policy rate the closest period becomes Feb 2001; without inflation it becomes Jul 1999. The match is unstable. Monthly observations are from August, deliberately lagged; the curve is from October 9. Revised data do not recreate what investors knew at the time.

02 / SECTOR PULSE

Technology

Last this week.
First this month.

#111W · 5 sessions-2.3%
#11M · 21 sessions+4.8%

Technology, among 11 sectors. Its weak week has not erased its monthly lead.

Sector returns and historical context

The closest rotation is 2025-11-05, but week-only matching picks 2024-09-09. The resemblance is unstable. Shared history starts 2018-06-19.

  • Consumer staples+4.2% / +1.9%
  • Utilities+4.2% / -1.1%
  • Energy+4.0% / +1.9%
  • Real estate+3.1% / -2.6%
  • Health care+2.8% / +4.4%
  • Financials+2.2% / -3.5%
  • Consumer discretionary+1.7% / -0.4%
  • Materials-0.1% / -2.5%
  • Communication services-0.1% / -0.7%
  • Industrials-0.6% / -1.6%
  • Technology-2.3% / +4.8%

Returns shown as one week / one month.

03 / BEST RHYME

SPY is rhyming with June 2021

NOW 2026THEN 2021
Today’s S&P 500 (SPY) path and its June 2021 historical analogThe 2026 current path and 2021 historical path converge at one TODAY point equal to 100. The current line stops there, while only the historical 2021 line continues through 90 trading days of historical outcome.8590951001051102021 CONTINUED →HISTORICAL OUTCOME · NOT A FORECAST−90DTODAY+90D

Historical outcomes

What followed the matched period.

1M
+2.9%
3M
+5.4%
6M
+11.4%
MAX DRAWDOWN
-5.1%

Historical outcome — not a forecast.

Data through: 2026-10-12